Would you like to start a free subscription?
Remember me | Forgot password
For full content view: Log in Now!
In the Great and Silly Debate about global warming, a recent poll surprised me. But it wasn’t the results that were interesting; rather, it was the fact that a poll was taken at all. There is supposed to be some sort of danger in “consensus science.” But I have never agreed with that. Yes, of course there are dangers in most human endeavors—science is no different. Herd mentality, going along with the crowd so as to play it safe for the sake of one’s career—these are some of the worries with consensus science. But the alternatives are also rife with problems.
Still, I take comfort in the fact that some things in science, despite a lack of certainty, do have a consensus—most cancer treatments, for example. Or how much mercury is “safe” to eat. One cannot be an expert in all things, so most of the time I simply choose to trust those who are experts in a given field.
Peter Doran, University of Illinois at Chicago associate professor of earth and environmental sciences, along with former graduate student Maggie Zimmerman, conducted a survey. They sought the opinion of the most complete list of earth scientists they could find—those listed in the 2007 edition of the American Geological Institute’s Directory of Geoscience Departments. More than 10,200 experts in academia and government research centers around the world were emailed invitations to participate in an online poll. Computer IP addresses were used to prevent non-invitees and repeat voting. The nine-question survey was reviewed by a polling expert who checked for bias in phrasing.
The results found that earth scientists overwhelmingly (90%) agree that in the past 200 or so years, mean global temperatures have been rising.
This area of the site is restricted.
In order to gain access, please either Log
In, or subscribe to World Oil.
Two options are available to you for creating an account.
1. Get a Free Trial Subscription to World Oil Magazine and gain immediate access to select content on World Oil Online.
Start a Free Trial Subscription and gain immediate access to the complete current issue of World Oil Magazine. Plus, you’ll receive 3 upcoming issues of World Oil Magazine in print or digital format.* You also receive access to the Energy Events Calendar, Industry Statistics and WO Wire’s news and industry coverage.
2. Purchase a subscription to World Oil magazine and gain immediate
and complete access to World Oil Online. As a Total Access subscriber
you will have access to all areas of the site available to registered users and
free subscribers as well as having access to such premium content areas as:
Physical copies of this content may be available for purchase. Visit the Reprints & Back Issues section.
If you are already a paid subscriber and do not have access, please email CustomerService@worldoil.com.
World Oil's specialized upstream Engineering Data Tables featuring the Drill Bit Classifier, Tubing Tables and more. Get Total Access today.
Aberdeen - December 2-3
Calgary - December 8-8
Mangaf - December 8-10
All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws.
© 2014 World Oil. © 2014 Gulf Publishing Company.